LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Karnataka High Court Sets Aside Family Court's Maintenance Order; Emphasizes Financial Independence of Wife

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Karnataka High Court Sets Aside Family Court's Maintenance Order; Emphasizes Financial Independence of Wife

Court Holds That Wife Earning Rs.54,700/- Monthly and Maintaining Parents Cannot Claim Maintenance Under BNSS Section 144


In a significant judgment dated October 30, 2026, the Karnataka High Court, presided over by Justice Dr. Chillakur Sumalatha, overturned the Family Court's order directing a husband to pay maintenance to his wife. The wife had claimed Rs.85,000 per month under Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), but the Family Court had granted only Rs.20,000 per month, citing the husband's higher income.


The case arose from a dispute between Shubhrath A.R. (husband) and Chaithra M. (wife). The wife, a B.E. graduate in Computer Science employed as a Technical Writer with a monthly income of Rs.54,700, sought maintenance alleging neglect and refusal by her husband to maintain her. The husband, who earns Rs.2,00,000 per month but suffers from serious health conditions including Beta Thalassemia and acute diabetes, challenged the order on the ground that the wife was financially independent and capable of maintaining herself.


The High Court scrutinized the financial status and evidences presented by both parties. It was noted that the wife was not only earning sufficiently but was also incurring monthly expenses of approximately Rs.35,000 towards her parents, indicating her financial responsibility and independence. The Court emphasized the legal requirement under Section 144 BNSS that a wife must prove both neglect/refusal by the husband and her inability to maintain herself to claim maintenance.


Rejecting the Family Court's reasoning that the husband's higher income alone justifies maintenance, the Karnataka High Court held that mere comparative superiority in income does not warrant maintenance if the wife is self-sufficient. It was further observed that the husband's substantial medical expenses and financial obligations towards his parents were relevant factors in assessing his capacity to pay maintenance.


The Court highlighted the principles laid down in the Supreme Court's decision in Rajnesh v. Neha (2021) 2 SCC 324, affirming that maintenance is not an automatic entitlement based solely on income disparity but depends on the claimant's actual dependency status.


Consequently, the revision petition filed by the husband was allowed, and the Family Court's order directing monthly maintenance of Rs.20,000 was set aside. However, to keep the possibility of an amicable settlement open, the Court restrained the husband from initiating recovery proceedings for any maintenance amount already paid.


This judgment underscores the evolving jurisprudence under the BNSS, 2023, recognizing the financial autonomy of spouses and requiring clear proof of dependency for maintenance claims, thereby balancing the interests of both parties in matrimonial disputes.


Bottom Line:

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 144 - Maintenance to wife - Mere fact that husband earns more than wife does not by itself entitle wife to maintenance - Wife must establish that husband neglected or refused to maintain her and that she is unable to maintain herself - Where wife was well educated, gainfully employed, earning Rs.54,700/- per month and even maintaining her parents from her income, she could not be treated as dependent on husband - Family Court order granting maintenance of Rs.20,000/- per month set aside.


Statutory provision(s): Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 144


Shubhrath A.R. v. Chaithra M., (Karnataka) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3014548

Share this article: