Court holds PIL not a tool for policy disputes; upholds CESTAT's jurisdiction to interpret Foreign Trade Policy provisions
In a significant judgment dated November 11, 2026, the Madras High Court (Division Bench) dismissed a public interest litigation (PIL) petition filed by S. Santhosh Kumar challenging the implementation of the Duty Free Import Authorization (DFIA) scheme under the Foreign Trade Policy (FTP). The petitioner sought directions to customs authorities to enforce value caps and actual user conditions imposed via a public notice, and sought a declaration that rulings by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) do not bind the Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) on policy matters.
The petitioner contended that certain conditions introduced by DGFT through Public Notice No.41 dated November 2, 2016-specifically value caps and actual user requirements for inputs under the DFIA scheme-were being ignored by importers, leading to alleged misuse and revenue loss. He argued such conditions could only be imposed through a notification in the Official Gazette and not by a public notice. Additionally, the petition challenged the eligibility of DFIA exporters to claim benefits under the Remission of Duties and Taxes on Export Products (RoDTEP) scheme, asserting that DFIA exporters were unjustly obtaining double benefits.
The Court analyzed the scope and nature of PILs, emphasizing that PILs are intended for the protection of marginalized or disadvantaged groups who cannot access justice themselves, and not as a mechanism to resolve policy disputes or to reopen decisions made by other judicial or quasi-judicial forums. The Court noted that the petitioner failed to demonstrate good faith by not naming any specific importer or providing concrete evidence of alleged violations. The reliance on internet reports and tribunal orders from other jurisdictions without local instances was considered insufficient.
Importantly, the Court examined the legal force of conditions imposed by DGFT through a public notice. It observed that a writ of mandamus requiring enforcement of such conditions cannot be issued where the legal validity of those conditions is under serious doubt. The Court opined that if the Central Government or DGFT believes such conditions are necessary to protect revenue, the appropriate remedy is to issue a proper notification in the Official Gazette, which is a policy decision beyond the Court's purview.
Regarding the petitioner's request for a broad inquiry and issuance of show cause notices against unnamed importers and officers, the Court held that recovery of customs duty is governed by the Customs Act, 1962, which requires notice to specific persons on particular facts by proper officers. Therefore, a roving inquiry in a PIL was held to be impermissible.
The Court also upheld the jurisdiction of the CESTAT under Section 129A of the Customs Act, 1962, to interpret FTP provisions in cases involving customs exemptions. It rejected the petitioner's attempt to declare that CESTAT decisions do not bind DGFT, stating that Paragraph 2.58 of FTP which makes DGFT's interpretation final is a policy provision and does not oust the statutory jurisdiction of the Tribunal. Moreover, as the Union of India had not expressed grievance over the tribunal orders cited by the petitioner, the petitioner lacked locus standi to challenge those decisions.
Ultimately, the Madras High Court dismissed the petition, holding that the relief sought was not maintainable in a PIL and emphasizing that policy decisions must be left to the executive and legislature.
This judgment clarifies that PILs cannot be used as vehicles to challenge trade policy or to enforce conditions whose legal validity is questionable. It also affirms the concurrent jurisdiction of CESTAT in interpreting foreign trade policy provisions when adjudicating customs matters.
Bottom Line:
Public Interest Litigation (PIL) cannot be used as a tool to settle policy matters, and the court must ensure that the petitioner is acting in good faith with facts pleaded carefully. Relief sought must be one that the court can properly grant.
Statutory provision(s):
Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992 Sections 9, 19; Customs Act, 1962 Section 129A
S. Santhosh Kumar v. Union of India, (Madras)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3024954