Court holds police report filed under Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, sufficient despite absence of CCTV and mobile data; emphasizes accused's lack of right to dictate investigation scope.
In a significant judgment delivered on November 5, 2026, the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court dismissed a criminal revision petition filed by M. Alex seeking statutory bail under Section 187(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023. The petitioner challenged the dismissal of his earlier bail plea by the Special Court for EC and NDPS Act Cases, Pudukkottai, contending that the police report filed against him was incomplete due to the alleged non-inclusion of critical evidence such as CCTV footage from a toll plaza and Call Detail Records (CDR)/Customer Acquisition Form (CAF) details of a mobile phone linked to the conspiracy.
Background:
The case arose from a narcotics seizure incident dated April 13, 2025, where the petitioner was accused of conspiring with a co-accused to possess and transport 950 grams of Methamphetamine. The petitioner was arrested and remanded on April 14, 2025. The Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) filed a police report on October 3, 2025, and the case is ongoing before the special court. The petitioner's challenge centered on the police report's failure to include all investigative materials, specifically the CCTV footage from Palaya Gandarvakkottai Toll Plaza and the mobile phone data, arguing that these omissions rendered the report incomplete and entitled him to statutory bail.
Court's Analysis:
Justice B. Murugesan thoroughly examined the scope of "completeness" of a police report under BNSS, particularly Sections 187, 189, 190, and 193. The court clarified that a police report must contain "sufficient evidence or reasonable grounds of suspicion" for the Magistrate to take cognizance, but it need not include every piece of material evidence collected during the investigation. It emphasized that the police report's role is to furnish the court with enough information to proceed, with additional evidence to be produced during the trial.
Importantly, the court referred to authoritative Supreme Court precedents, including the recent judgments in Shaurya Sunil Singh v. CBI (2026), CBI v. Kapil Wadhawan, and Central Bureau of Investigation v. R.S. Pai, to reinforce that:
- The right to statutory/default bail under Section 187(3) BNSS extinguishes once a valid police report is filed within the prescribed time frame.
- Non-inclusion of all documents or evidence in the initial police report does not invalidate it or entitle the accused to statutory bail, as further investigation and submission of additional reports is permitted under Section 193(9) BNSS.
- The accused does not have the right to dictate the manner or method of investigation or compel the inclusion of specific materials in the police report.
The court also noted that the CCTV footage had been preserved and forwarded to the special court, which was directed to have it retrieved by the Central Forensic Science Laboratory, Hyderabad. However, the delay caused by procedural requirements such as providing hard disks for data retrieval did not render the police report incomplete.
Decision:
The Madras High Court upheld the order of the special court dismissing the statutory bail petition. It ruled that the police report filed by the NCB was complete within the meaning of the BNSS, sufficiently enabling the Magistrate to take cognizance and proceed with trial. The petitioner's challenge based on the alleged incomplete police report was rejected, and the court directed the special court to conclude the trial within two months.
Significance:
This ruling reinforces the principle that a police report need not be an exhaustive compendium of all evidence gathered but must present sufficient material for judicial cognizance. It underscores the accused's limited role during investigation and confirms that statutory bail under BNSS cannot be granted merely because certain evidence is pending or excluded from the initial police report. The judgment aligns with Supreme Court jurisprudence emphasizing expeditious investigation and trial without compromising procedural fairness.
Bottom Line:
Statutory bail under S.187(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, cannot be granted merely on the grounds that certain evidence, such as CCTV footage or CDR/CAF details, is not included in the police report if the report otherwise complies with legal requirements and enables the court to take cognizance.
Statutory provision(s):
Sections 187(3), 189, 190, 193(3), 193(6), 193(9) of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023; Sections 22(c), 27A, 28, 29, 8(c) NDPS Act, 1985; Section 173 CrPC (analogous references).
M. Alex v. Union of India, (Madras)(Madurai Bench) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3033592