Resolution Professional's Forensic Audit Reveals Preferential Payments to Related Party Directors; Tribunal Orders Repayment with Interest under Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016
In a significant ruling dated October 15, 2026, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Kochi Bench, directed two directors of Jomer Properties and Investments Pvt Ltd to repay a total sum of Rs. 15,11,536 to the Corporate Debtor's account managed by the Resolution Professional (RP). The order was passed in IA (IBC)/7/KOB of 2025 arising from the ongoing Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) against Jomer Properties.
The matter was initiated by Mr. Kizhakkekara Kuriakose Jose, the Resolution Professional of Jomer Properties, who filed the application under Section 43(1) and 60(5)(c) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) seeking to avoid certain preferential transactions made to related party directors during the two-year look-back period prior to the insolvency commencement date of February 16, 2024.
A forensic audit, authorized by the Committee of Creditors (CoC), scrutinized transactions between February 16, 2022, and February 16, 2024. It revealed that Mr. M.M. Jose, a former director and related party, had received Rs.13,09,000 without adequate documentation to prove that these payments were for legitimate business expenses or in the ordinary course of business. Similarly, Mr. Renju Jose, an Additional Director and later Managing Director, received an excess payment of Rs.2,02,536 related to advances for land/building transactions, which also lacked proper justification or supporting documents.
The NCLT Bench, comprising Mr. Vinay Goel (Judicial Member) and Mr. Ravichandran Ramasamy (Technical Member), held that these payments constituted preferential transactions under Section 43 of the IBC. The Tribunal relied heavily on the definition of "related party" under Section 5(24) of the Code, noting that both directors were explicitly disclosed as key managerial personnel in the company's audited financial statements. The transactions, made within the statutory two-year look-back period for related parties, were found to have placed the directors in a more beneficial position than other creditors, violating the equitable principles of insolvency distribution under Section 53.
The Tribunal also drew upon the Supreme Court judgment in Anuj Jain IRP for Jaypee Infratech Ltd. v. Axis Bank Ltd., which set out the criteria for determining preferential transactions. Applying these principles, it was found that the respondents failed to produce any evidence or explanation to rebut the presumption of preference or to show that the transactions were made in the ordinary course of business.
Given the respondents' non-cooperation and absence from proceedings, the Tribunal proceeded ex parte and directed them to repay the identified amounts with interest at 12% per annum or the SBI Prime Lending Rate plus 2%, whichever is higher, within 30 days. The order also clarified that the earlier related case involving ITMA Hotels India Pvt. Ltd., a sister concern, did not influence this decision, as the transactions and CIRP proceedings were distinct.
This ruling reinforces the scrutiny of related party transactions during insolvency proceedings and underscores the fiduciary responsibility of directors to avoid preferential payments that prejudice other creditors. It also highlights the importance of forensic audits in uncovering undisclosed or questionable financial transactions during CIRP.
Bottom Line:
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 - Preferential transactions - Payments made by Corporate Debtor to related party directors during the two-year look-back period, towards antecedent liabilities, without supporting documents to show ordinary course of business, are liable to be avoided and restored to the Corporate Debtor.
Statutory provision(s):
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Sections 2(24), 5(24), 43, 44, 53, 60(5)(c)