LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

NCLT Bengaluru Bench Dismisses Third-Party Claim Over Machinery in Corporate Debtor's Liquidation Estate

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
NCLT Bengaluru Bench Dismisses Third-Party Claim Over Machinery in Corporate Debtor's Liquidation Estate

Tribunal holds that mere invoices and assertions insufficient to exclude assets from liquidation; Liquidator not obligated to appoint experts at eleventh hour to stall e-auction


In a significant ruling on October 6, 2026, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Bengaluru Bench, dismissed the application filed by M/s BP Metal Packs Private Limited challenging the inclusion of certain machinery and components in the liquidation estate of M/s Metal Closures Private Limited, a corporate debtor undergoing liquidation. The applicant claimed ownership over specific machinery, components, upgrades, spares, dies, tooling, and accessories located at the debtor's factory premises and sought the appointment of an independent technical expert to segregate and identify their assets before the scheduled e-auction of the debtor's assets.


The dispute arose during the liquidation process initiated under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 ("the Code") after M/s Metal Closures Private Limited was admitted to Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process in December 2018 and subsequently ordered liquidation in September 2019. The applicant, engaged in manufacturing metal products and operating from the same premises since 2017, contended that it had independently purchased and installed certain machinery and components that were physically embedded or attached to the debtor's machinery but remained its exclusive property. Despite repeated requests to the liquidator to identify and exclude these assets from the liquidation estate, the applicant argued that the liquidator proceeded without segregating these assets and issued an e-auction sale notice including them.


The Tribunal clarified that under Section 36(4)(a) of the Code, assets owned by third parties but held in possession of the corporate debtor can be excluded from the liquidation estate only if the third party establishes a prima facie proprietary right over such assets through clear, contemporaneous, and technical evidence. Mere possession of invoices, purchase documents, or a self-prepared comparative statement by the applicant does not suffice to displace the liquidator's custody or extend the exclusion. The Bench emphasized that the burden of proof lies squarely on the third party asserting ownership and cannot be shifted onto the liquidator to conduct a technical investigation or appoint experts, especially at a belated stage of the liquidation process.


Notably, the Tribunal underscored the applicant's conduct, observing that it had been aware of the ongoing liquidation proceedings for several months and had corresponded with the liquidator since June 2026 regarding the disputed assets. The applicant failed to produce any independent technical report or contemporaneous item-wise schedule identifying and segregating its assets from those of the corporate debtor. The Tribunal held that the applicant's delay in raising the claim only days before the e-auction scheduled for October 8, 2026, was unacceptable and would unfairly impede the timely realization of assets under the Code.


Consequently, the NCLT rejected the application seeking to stay the e-auction and the appointment of a technical expert. However, it was clarified that the dismissal of the application does not amount to a declaration of title in favor of the corporate debtor over the disputed assets. The applicant remains free to pursue other legal remedies to establish ownership, subject to the provisions of the Code and the rights arising from the liquidation process.


This ruling reinforces the principle that the liquidation estate is confined to the assets owned by the corporate debtor and that third-party ownership claims must be substantiated with clear and decisive evidence. It also highlights the Tribunal's commitment to ensuring the liquidation process proceeds without undue delay or disruption caused by belated and unsupported claims.


Bottom Line:

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 - Liquidation - Third-party claiming ownership over machinery/components lying in corporate debtor's premises must establish prima facie proprietary right by clear contemporaneous and technical evidence - Mere invoices, comparative statement and assertion of ownership are insufficient - Liquidator cannot be compelled at belated stage to appoint expert and stall e-auction, Section 36(4)(a) exclusion from liquidation estate is not attracted on mere claim.


Statutory provision(s):

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Sections 36(4)(a), 36(3), 60(5)


BP Metal Packs Private Limited v. Ramanathan Bhuvaneshwari, (NCLT)(Bengaluru Bench) : Law Finder Doc Id # 2995753

Share this article: