LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Orissa High Court Appoints Substituted Arbitrator Following Death of Two Tribunal Members in Core Minerals Dispute

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Orissa High Court Appoints Substituted Arbitrator Following Death of Two Tribunal Members in Core Minerals Dispute

Court holds arbitration clause binding despite death of arbitrators; directs continuation of proceedings with newly appointed presiding arbitrator


In a significant judgment delivered on 12th November 2026, the Orissa High Court addressed the crucial issue of appointing substituted arbitrators following the death of two members of an arbitral tribunal in the dispute between Core Minerals and Himanghini Singh. The case arose from two agreements executed in 2002 concerning iron ore mining and sales, which included an arbitration clause requiring disputes to be resolved by a tribunal of two arbitrators, one appointed by each party, and a presiding arbitrator.


The petitioner, Core Minerals, moved the court under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 ("the Act") seeking the appointment of arbitrators after the death of the presiding arbitrator and the arbitrator it had nominated. The respondent party's predecessor had also passed away, and the respondent showed an uncooperative stance by not responding to repeated notices for appointing arbitrators.


The Court observed that while the mandate of the arbitral tribunal terminates upon the death of arbitrators, the arbitration clause itself remains binding on the parties. This means that the arbitration agreement continues to require resolution of disputes through arbitration, and the tribunal must be reconstituted to proceed. The Court clarified that Section 29A of the Act, which prescribes time limits for arbitration awards, was not applicable in this situation because the tribunal had become defunct due to the death of arbitrators, thus requiring fresh appointments.


Relying on Supreme Court precedents, including Huawei Technologies Company Limited v. Sterlite Technologies Limited (2016) and Shailesh Dhairyawan v. Mohan Balkrishna Lulla (2016), the Court emphasized that substituted arbitrators must be appointed according to the "rules" governing the original appointment procedure specified in the arbitration clause. The Court further noted that the death of an arbitrator does not invalidate the arbitration agreement.


Applying these principles, the Orissa High Court appointed Mr. Justice Ananga Kumar Patnaik, Former Judge of the Supreme Court of India, as the Presiding Arbitrator. The arbitrators appointed by the respective parties would continue, and the reconstituted tribunal was directed to proceed from the stage where the previous tribunal ceased functioning. The Court also directed that the arbitration be conducted under the aegis of the Orissa High Court Arbitration Centre and encouraged adherence to the time limits under Section 29A of the Act for the award.


This judgment underscores the judiciary's commitment to ensuring continuity and efficacy in arbitration proceedings, especially when unforeseen circumstances such as the death of arbitrators arise. It also reinforces that arbitration clauses remain enforceable and binding, and courts have the authority to intervene to preserve the arbitration process.


Bottom Line:

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 - Appointment of substituted arbitrator - Mandate of Arbitral Tribunal terminates upon death of arbitrators - Arbitration clause remains binding on parties, enabling the appointment of substituted arbitrators.


Statutory provision(s):

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 11(6), 15, 29A


Core Minerals v. Himanghini Singh, (Orissa) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3033339

Share this article: