LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Uttarakhand HC Dismisses Election Petition Against Lohaghat MLA

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Uttarakhand HC Dismisses Election Petition Against Lohaghat MLA

Court finds no proof of disqualification under Section 9-A, no fatal defect in Form 26 affidavit, and no concealment of material facts by returned candidate


The Uttarakhand High Court has dismissed an election petition challenging the victory of Khushal Singh Adhikari from the 54-Lohaghat Assembly Constituency, holding that allegations of disqualification, improper nomination acceptance, and concealment of facts were not proved.


Justice Pankaj Purohit ruled that the petitioner, Puran Singh Fartyal, failed to establish that the returned candidate was disqualified under Section 9-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The court observed that mere continuation of government-sponsored road works by a partnership firm was not enough to show a subsisting contract personally binding the candidate with the State Government. It held that the essential statutory link between the candidate and the “appropriate Government” had not been proved.


The court relied on Supreme Court precedents, including Kartar Singh Bhadana and Shrikant v. Vasantrao, to reiterate that disqualification under Section 9-A arises only when all statutory conditions are satisfied. It noted that the petitioner had shown ongoing PMGSY-related works, but not that the returned candidate himself remained contractually bound in a manner attracting the provision.


On the issue of Form 26 affidavits under Rule 4-A of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961, the court found that although the original affidavit contained deficiencies, the candidate had filed supplementary affidavits before scrutiny, and the Returning Officer had accepted them within time. The court held that no material defect remained that could invalidate the nomination.


The High Court also rejected the allegation that the candidate concealed material facts or made false declarations in Form 26. It found that the evidence did not prove that the candidate had a subsisting disclosable contract on the relevant date or that the declaration of “not applicable” was false. The court said ongoing works alone were insufficient to prove concealment or misrepresentation.


Concluding that none of the grounds urged by the petitioner were established, the court dismissed the election petition.


Bottom Line:

Election Law - Representation of the People Act, 1951 - Disqualification under Section 9-A for government contracts, non-compliance with Rule 4-A of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961, and concealment of material information in Form 26 do not stand proved in absence of sufficient evidence establishing a subsisting contractual obligation with the State Government or falsity of declarations in the affidavit.


Statutory provision(s): Representation of the People Act, 1951 Sections 9-A, 33-A, 80, 80-A, 84, 100, Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 Rule 4-A, Rule 94-A, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Order 7 Rule 11


Puran Singh Fartyal v. Kushal Singh, (Uttarakhand) : Law Finder Doc id # 3202000

Share this article: