LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Allahabad High Court Quashes Expanded Sports Quota List in UP Police Recruitment, Calls Late-Included Candidates’ List “Non Est”

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Allahabad High Court Quashes Expanded Sports Quota List in UP Police Recruitment, Calls Late-Included Candidates’ List “Non Est”

Court holds six candidates were wrongly allowed into trials after deadline; directs Board to finalize selection only from original list of 120 eligible candidates.


The Allahabad High Court’s Lucknow Bench has set aside an expanded shortlist in the Uttar Pradesh Police sports quota recruitment process, holding that the inclusion of six additional candidates after the prescribed deadline was illegal and without authority of law.


Justice Rajeev Singh delivered the ruling in Writ-A No. 7813 of 2026 filed by Nitish Kumar, who had challenged the final shortlist issued on 17 July 2026 for recruitment under the Uttar Pradesh Police (Kushal Khiladiyon Ki Bharti Evam Bina Paari Padonnati) Niyamavali, 2021.


According to the petitioner, the recruitment process for constables under the sports quota was initiated through an advertisement dated 12 December 2023, followed by a clarification on age relaxation issued on 3 January 2024. After the document verification stage and the expiry of a notice dated 3 November 2025, the Uttar Pradesh Police Recruitment and Promotion Board prepared a list of 120 eligible candidates for the cross-country sports trial. The petitioner’s name appeared in that list.


However, the petitioner alleged that later, a fresh list of 126 candidates was prepared, and six candidates who had not figured in the original list were allowed to participate in the trials. He contended that this was done contrary to the notice and without following the prescribed procedure. He further argued that some of these candidates, including Ravi Kumar Pal, Ashish Kumar Patel, and Rohan Kumar, were permitted to take part in the trials despite submitting their representations beyond the stipulated time.


The State defended the process by relying on para 9.13 of the recruitment board’s directive manual, arguing that documents not initially enclosed with the application could be considered at the verification stage. It was also submitted that candidates were given a chance to submit representations within three days of the notice dated 3 November 2025, and that some candidates were later included after scrutiny. The State, however, did not place the representations or the orders passed on them before the Court.


After examining the record, the Court found that the Board had already finalized and published a list of 120 eligible candidates after the deadline fixed by the notice. It observed that the subsequent inclusion of six more candidates in a list of 126, without any disclosed reasons or supporting orders, was impermissible.


The Court specifically held that six candidates — Ganesh Kumar Bind, Indra Jeet, Ashish Kumar, Rohan Kumar, Ravi Kumar Pal, and Ashish Kumar Patel — were allowed to participate in the trials illegally and contrary to the notice dated 3 November 2025. It therefore declared the later list “non est,” meaning it had no legal existence.


In a significant direction, the Court ordered the Chairman of the U.P. Police Recruitment and Promotion Board to finalize the selection process only on the basis of the original list of 120 candidates prepared pursuant to the notice dated 3 November 2025. The Court further directed that if the petitioner is found suitable, the appointment process should be completed within six weeks by passing a reasoned and speaking order.


Allowing the petition, the Court reaffirmed that recruitment authorities must strictly follow the prescribed procedure and cannot alter shortlist eligibility after the deadline in a manner that prejudices other candidates.


Bottom Line:

Recruitment process - Inclusion of candidates contrary to prescribed procedure - Selection list of candidates prepared after the stipulated deadline is **non est** - Authorities directed to finalize selection based on the original list prepared within the stipulated deadline.


Statutory provision(s): Uttar Pradesh Police (Kushal Khiladiyon Ki Bharti Evam Bina Paari Padonnati) Niyamavali, 2021, Para 9.13 of U.P. Police Recruitment and Promotion Board’s Nirdesh Pustika


Nitish Kumar v. State of U.P., (All)(Lucknow) : Law Finder Doc id # 3201955

Share this article: