Aadhaar card not conclusive proof of date of birth; court relies on ESIC records and holds termination of workwoman illegal for want of compliance with Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act.
The Delhi High Court has dismissed a writ petition filed by M/s J. J. Electronics challenging a Labour Court award in favour of a workwoman, holding that the employer failed to prove that she had reached the age of superannuation. Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri ruled that the burden of establishing retirement on superannuation lay on the management, and that an Aadhaar card could not by itself be treated as conclusive proof of date of birth.
The dispute arose after the workwoman, employed as a “Finishing Man” since 1981, alleged that her services were illegally terminated on 20 May 2017 when she demanded revised minimum wages and her pending salary. She claimed that the management ended her employment in violation of Sections 25F and 25G of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The management, however, argued that she had attained the age of 58 years on that date and therefore retired automatically under the establishment’s retirement policy.
The Labour Court had rejected the management’s defence, noting that the employer had itself earlier furnished the workwoman’s date of birth as 20 May 1960 to the Employees’ State Insurance Corporation in 2010. In contrast, the Aadhaar card produced by the workwoman showed her date of birth as 20 May 1959. Since the management did not produce the original record on which the ESIC entry was based, the Labour Court drew an adverse inference against it and held that the workwoman’s date of birth was 20 May 1960. It also found that the employer failed to prove resignation, voluntary retirement, or medical incapacity.
Upholding the Labour Court’s reasoning, the High Court referred to recent judicial precedent, including the Supreme Court’s decision in Saroj v. Iffco-Tokio General Insurance Co., and reiterated that Aadhaar is primarily proof of identity and not proof of date of birth. The Court also relied on the fact that the ESIC record was created years before the dispute arose, when there was no apparent reason to manipulate the date of birth. The management’s failure to challenge the ESIC witness or produce supporting documents further weakened its case.
Justice Ohri held that once superannuation was not proved, the termination amounted to retrenchment. Since the employer had not complied with Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, the termination was illegal. The Court also observed that the Labour Court’s findings were based on evidence and were not perverse, and therefore did not warrant interference under writ jurisdiction.
Accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed. The High Court directed that the amount deposited with the Registrar General be released to the workwoman, and any remaining dues be paid by the management within four weeks.
Bottom Line:
Burden of proving superannuation lies on the employer, and an Aadhaar card is not conclusive proof of date of birth for determining retirement age.
Statutory provision(s): Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Section 2(oo)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Section 25G of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
M/s J. J. Electronics v. Smt. Rosamma Joy, (Delhi) : Law Finder Doc id # 3201976