LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Allahabad High Court Warns Basic Education Officials in Contempt Case Over Non-Compliance of Orders

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Allahabad High Court Warns Basic Education Officials in Contempt Case Over Non-Compliance of Orders

Court finds prima facie willful disobedience despite no operative stay from Supreme Court, asks respondents to secure favourable order or appear personally on next date


The Allahabad High Court has taken a stern view of alleged non-compliance with its earlier directions by officials of the Basic Education Department and warned that contempt proceedings may be initiated if they fail to justify their conduct.


Justice Piyush Agrawal, while hearing Contempt Application (Civil) No. 7677 of 2026 filed by Arun Pratap Singh Parmar against Surendra Tiwari, Secretary, and another official, observed that the material placed on record clearly indicated willful disobedience of the court’s order.


The matter came up in pursuance of an earlier order dated 28 October 2026. During the hearing, instructions dated 2 November 2026, signed by the Secretary, Basic Education, were placed before the court. Relying on those instructions, counsel for the respondents argued that a similar issue was pending before the Supreme Court in SLP No. 21273 of 2024 and therefore a final list could not be drawn.


This submission was strongly opposed by the applicant. The applicant’s counsel pointed to earlier contempt proceedings before the Lucknow Bench of the High Court in connected matters, where the State had been given liberty either to comply with the order or obtain a favourable order. The applicant further referred to proceedings before the Supreme Court in SLP No. 18730 of 2026, where notice had been issued and the apex court specifically sought instructions on why the High Court’s order had not been complied with despite there being no operative stay.


According to the applicant, after notice from the Supreme Court, the respondent authorities had issued an appointment order dated 7 May 2026 in that matter, showing that compliance was possible when pressure was applied. On this basis, it was argued that the authorities were acting selectively and were deliberately disobeying the court’s directions in the present case.


Counsel for the respondents sought some more time. However, the High Court was not inclined to ignore the pattern reflected in the record. In its order dated 6 November 2026, the court stated that the statements made and documents placed before it “clearly indicate” that the respondents had willfully disobeyed the order of the court.


The court accordingly directed the respondents to either produce a favourable order by the next date or appear in person for initiation of contempt proceedings against them. The matter has been directed to be listed afresh on 1 December 2026.


The order underscores the High Court’s view that mere pendency of a similar matter before the Supreme Court does not automatically justify non-compliance, especially when there is no stay operating against the implementation of the court’s directions. The case is likely to be closely watched as it may determine the accountability of senior officials in matters involving execution of judicial orders.


Bottom Line:

Contempt of court proceedings initiated against respondents for willful disobedience of court orders, with the court directing respondents to either produce a favourable order or appear in person for further proceedings.


Statutory provision(s): Section 12, Contempt of Courts Act, 1971


Arun Pratap Singh Parmar v. Surendra Tiwari, (Allahabad) : Law Finder Doc id # 3102117

Share this article: