LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Calcutta High Court Sets Aside Rape Conviction of Two Men, Citing Lack of Medical and Forensic Evidence

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Calcutta High Court Sets Aside Rape Conviction of Two Men, Citing Lack of Medical and Forensic Evidence

Court says victim’s testimony, though important, was not supported by injuries, medical report, or seized clothes; trial court’s reasoning was found legally flawed.


Kolkata: The Calcutta High Court has overturned the conviction of Palash Das and another accused, who had been sentenced to life imprisonment for gang rape under Section 376(2)(g) of the Indian Penal Code, holding that the prosecution failed to produce sufficient corroborative evidence.


A division bench of Justice Rajasekhar Mantha and Justice Anuj Singh allowed the criminal appeal and set aside the conviction and sentence passed by the Fast Track Court, Kalna, Burdwan, in October 2018. The appellants were ordered to be released forthwith, subject to execution of bonds under Section 437A CrPC.


The case arose from a complaint by the victim, who alleged that on August 19, 2006, she was abducted by the two appellants and another man, taken to a verandah, disrobed, and sexually assaulted. The complaint, however, was lodged only on August 22, 2006. During trial, the prosecution examined the victim, her parents, a local witness, and the investigating officer. Several witnesses turned hostile or gave statements inconsistent with the prosecution version.


The High Court noted that while a conviction for rape can rest on the sole testimony of the victim if it is of sterling quality, the evidence in this case was not supported by medical or forensic material. No complete medical examination report was produced, the victim’s clothes were not seized or sent for forensic examination, and there was no evidence of bodily injuries or traces of sexual assault.


The bench also found contradictions in the prosecution evidence. The victim’s mother had told the doctor that the girl was menstruating on the relevant date and had only been tied to a tree and inappropriately touched, which was inconsistent with the allegation of gang rape. The court further observed that neither the victim nor other witnesses described any injuries that would ordinarily be expected if she had resisted an attack by three men.


Criticising the trial court’s approach, the High Court said it was erroneous to draw an inference of guilt merely because the defence had not specifically denied the rape suggestion in cross-examination. The court reiterated that the burden always lies on the prosecution to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt.


Finding the investigation “perfunctory” and the evidence insufficient, the bench concluded that the conviction could not stand. The appeal was therefore allowed, and the appellants were acquitted.


Bottom Line:

Criminal law - Conviction under Section 376(2)(g) IPC set aside due to lack of corroborative evidence, including absence of medical examination report, forensic evidence, and inconsistencies in prosecution witnesses' statements.


Statutory provision(s): Section 376(2)(g) IPC, Section 437A CrPC, Section 164 CrPC, Section 161 CrPC, Section 481 BNSS, 2023


Palash Das v. State of West Bengal, (Calcutta)(DB) : Law Finder Doc id # 3102208

Share this article: