LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

SC seeks response from Congress, AAP on traders' plea against protests

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
SC seeks response from Congress, AAP on traders' plea against protests

New Delhi, Nov 18 The Supreme Court on Wednesday sought responses from the Congress, Cockroach Janata Party, All India Student Association (AISA), and the Aam Aadmi Party on an amended plea of traders' bodies seeking to denotify Ramlila Maidan as a designated protest site, claiming that agitations undermined their right to do business.


The top court also issued notices to the Centre, the Delhi government and the city police commissioner on the amended petition of Delhi Kirana Committee and the Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchant Association.


A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, on November 3, had asked traders' bodies to make these agitating outfits parties to the petition.


During the festival season, the traders' bodies had sought a halt on protests at central Delhi's Ramlila Maidan, saying such sites cannot be occupied for "all times to come."


On Wednesday, the bench took note of the plea and the submissions of senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for traders' bodies, and issued notices to the parties.


"The amended writ petition taken on record. Let notices be issued to the newly-added respondents … The first category concerns the right of protesters to protest. Mr Rohatgi's matter concerns the rights of others, their competing fundamental rights. Both will have to be taken together," the bench said.


Competing fundamental rights, to protest and to run businesses, must be balanced, the bench said.


The CJI said he will notify hearing dates for separate categories of cases related to recent protests in Delhi and elsewhere.


Among the pleas up for hearing is a petition filed by Rajya Sabha MP and CPI (M) leader M A Baby, asserting the right to protest on November 27.


Rohatgi, in his submission, raised concerns over protests disrupting business activities in and around wholesale markets near Ramlila Maidan.


In fact, he said, the traders' bodies oppose Ramlila Maidan being notified as one of the designated protest sites in the national capital, as the area is a hub of business activity.


Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, supported Rohatgi, saying that the traders' plea needed to be heard alongwith main batch of petitions relating to the right to protest.


Rohatgi earlier submitted that prolonged protests were adversely affecting commercial establishments, particularly during the festival season, and claimed that businesses had suffered losses of thousands of crores.


The CJI had then emphasised that the right to protest cannot be exercised in a manner that indefinitely deprives others of access to designated protest sites or their livelihood.


The top court was hearing a litany of petitions, including those protesting mass detention, police brutality, closure of metro stations and internet shutdown during the recent protests in the capital.


"You can't occupy a protest site for all times to come. There are other protesters. Where will farmers, journalists, lawyers, etc., go? Where will the trade unions go? Where will the homeless go? Everyone has the right to protest. Designated time must be given for a designated period," the CJI said.


"We are not talking about trade merely in terms of commercial establishments. We are talking about the source of livelihood of a daily-wage worker. Where does that person go for his daily bread?" CJI Kant said.


On October 15, the bench sought responses from the Election Commission and others on a plea filed by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and 12 opposition leaders over alleged large-scale voter deletions and SIR irregularities.

Share this article: