Court says disciplinary findings were based on conjectures, and punishment was grossly disproportionate in light of the employee’s illness explanation and medical records.
The Supreme Court has restored the service of a Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) constable who had been removed from service for overstaying leave by 99 days, holding that the disciplinary authorities and the Division Bench of the Patna High Court erred in treating his absence as wilful misconduct without properly examining his explanation and medical evidence.
A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh allowed the appeal filed by Mithilesh Kumar Pathak and set aside the Patna High Court Division Bench judgment dated 5 May 2010, which had reinstated the order removing him from service. The Court restored the Single Judge’s decision that had quashed the disciplinary action.
The appellant, posted with the 54th Battalion of the CRPF in Anantnag, Jammu and Kashmir, had been granted casual leave from 21 September 2000 to 12 October 2000 on account of his wife’s illness. He failed to rejoin duty on 13 October 2000 and returned only on 19 January 2001. The department treated this as unauthorized absence and issued a charge memorandum alleging both absence without permission and disobedience of orders for failing to respond to letters directing him to report back.
Before the enquiry officer, the constable claimed that he himself had fallen ill with infective hepatitis while at his village in Bihar and had undergone treatment. He produced medical prescriptions, pathological reports, medicine receipts and a fitness certificate. However, the enquiry officer rejected these materials, mainly on the basis that the documents did not bear hospital registration numbers and that the same pen appeared to have been used in the prescriptions and bills. On that reasoning, the officer concluded that the documents were fabricated.
The Supreme Court found this approach unsustainable. It held that absence from duty does not automatically amount to wilful misconduct and that the surrounding circumstances, explanation offered by the employee and supporting evidence must be assessed before reaching such a conclusion. The Court observed that the enquiry officer had drawn adverse inferences from conjectures and surmises, without verifying the authenticity of the documents from the treating doctor or the medical establishment. Mere similarity in ink or handwriting could not, by itself, prove fabrication.
The Bench also rejected the view that the punishment of removal from service was justified merely because the appellant belonged to a disciplined force. While acknowledging the importance of discipline in a uniformed force, the Court emphasized that punishment must be proportionate to the gravity of the misconduct. In the facts of the case, removal from service for a 99-day overstay was held to be “grossly disproportionate,” especially when the employee had claimed illness and supported his case with medical records.
The Court referred to earlier precedents on judicial review in disciplinary matters, including State of Andhra Pradesh v. S. Sree Rama Rao and B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India, reiterating that courts should not ordinarily reappreciate evidence in departmental proceedings, but may interfere where findings are based on irrelevant considerations, violate natural justice, or are arbitrary. It held that the Single Judge had correctly interfered because the disciplinary findings were not based on sound reasoning, whereas the Division Bench had exceeded the limits of judicial review by restoring the punishment.
Accordingly, the Supreme Court directed the respondents to reinstate the appellant immediately and pay him 50% of the back wages for the period between removal and reinstatement, along with all consequential benefits.
Statutory provision(s): Rule 27(c)(4) of the CRPF Rules, 1955, Article 226 of the Constitution of India
Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India, (SC) : Law Finder Doc id # 3122589