LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Bombay High Court Rejects Stay on Ordinance Granting Voting Rights to Government Nominees in Large Federal Co-operative Societies

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Bombay High Court Rejects Stay on Ordinance Granting Voting Rights to Government Nominees in Large Federal Co-operative Societies

Court holds that Maharashtra Ordinance amending Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 is neither arbitrary nor tailor-made, and election proceedings to continue with safeguards pending final hearing


In a significant interim judgment dated November 9, 2026, the Bombay High Court's Circuit Bench at Kolhapur dismissed the petitioners' plea seeking a stay on the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026. The ordinance empowers government-nominated members in federal co-operative societies with annual turnover exceeding Rs. 500 crores to exercise voting rights in committee meetings, a provision which the petitioners challenged as arbitrary, unconstitutional, and designed to scuttle the democratic election process.


The dispute arose in the context of the Kolhapur Zilla Sahakari Dudh Utpadak Sangh Maryadit (Gokul), a federal co-operative society with a turnover exceeding Rs. 500 crores, where 25 directors were elected on October 19, 2026. The petitioners, who are among the elected directors, sought interim relief to prevent government nominees from participating or voting in the election of the chairman, scheduled for November 10, 2026.


The petitioners argued that the ordinance was promulgated after the election results were declared, thus altering the rules mid-process and infringing their vested rights. They contended that Section 27(9) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, explicitly prohibits government nominees from voting, and the ordinance's sudden promulgation was a "colourable exercise of power" aimed solely at the respondent society, thereby violating Article 14 of the Constitution.


Opposing the pleas, senior counsel for the State and respondents submitted that the ordinance was a considered legislative step, with proposals predating the election declaration, aimed at ensuring effective governance of large cooperative societies receiving government assistance. They emphasized the legal principle that courts must exercise judicial restraint in staying legislation unless it is glaringly unconstitutional or absurd. They also highlighted that the ordinance applies to multiple societies in Maharashtra, not just the respondent society, and serves the State's legitimate interest.


The Court, presided over by Justice Neeraj P. Dhote, examined the relevant constitutional and statutory provisions, as well as precedents from the Supreme Court of India, including the scope of judicial review over ordinances, principles of reasonable classification under Article 14, and conditions for granting interim relief against legislation.


Key observations by the Court included:

  • The Governor's power under Article 213 to promulgate ordinances is to be exercised with circumspection but is largely immune from judicial interference unless exercised mala fide or without any material basis.
  • The ordinance was not tailor-made for a single society; it applies to federal societies with turnover over Rs. 500 crores that receive government assistance, of which there are multiple in Maharashtra.
  • The proposal for the amendment existed before the election declaration, negating the claim of retrospective application or arbitrariness.
  • The Court must show judicial restraint in staying laws, especially those related to economic reforms, unless they are manifestly unconstitutional.
  • The petitioners failed to demonstrate irreparable injury or manifest unconstitutionality that would warrant an interim stay.
  • The election process was directed to continue with safeguards, including separate ballot boxes for elected directors and government nominees, and preservation of all election materials pending final adjudication.


Consequently, the interim application for stay was rejected, and the writ petitions were scheduled for final hearing on November 25, 2026. The Court's order preserves the democratic process while allowing judicial scrutiny of the ordinance's validity on merits.


This judgment underscores the judiciary's cautious approach in interfering with legislative policy, especially in cooperative governance, where the State's interest in oversight and assistance is balanced with democratic principles.


Bottom Line:

Ordinance promulgated to amend the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, enabling government-nominated members with voting rights in federal societies having annual turnover exceeding Rs. 500 crores, does not warrant stay as the proposal for amendment existed before elections and the ordinance is not prima facie arbitrary or tailored for a specific society.


Statutory provision(s):

Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 - Section 27(9), Section 73AAA; Constitution of India - Article 14, Article 213


Shri. Shashikant Anandrao Patil Chuyekar v. Presiding Officer, (Bombay)(Circuit Bench At Kolhapur) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019183

Share this article: