Court Rejects Petition Seeking Amendment of Recruitment Rules to Include Post-Graduation as Minimum Qualification, Holding 50% Marks in Graduation Not Arbitrary or Unconstitutional
In a significant judgment delivered on November 4, 2026, the Himachal Pradesh High Court (Division Bench comprising Justices Ajay Mohan Goel and Yogesh Jaswal) dismissed a writ petition filed by Som Krishan challenging the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of Special Educator (Class VI to Class XII) notified by the Himachal Pradesh Elementary Education Department on October 10, 2024.
The petitioner, Som Krishan, sought to compel the State respondents to amend Rule 7 of the Recruitment and Promotion Rules to incorporate Post-Graduation with 50% marks as an alternative minimum educational qualification for the post of Special Educator. He contended that the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) notification dated November 13, 2019, issued under Section 23(1) of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, allowed candidates with 50% marks either in Graduation or Post-Graduation to be eligible for such teaching posts. Since the petitioner had secured more than 50% marks in Post-Graduation but less than 50% in Graduation, he urged the court to direct the State to amend the rules accordingly.
The petitioner also challenged the requirement of six months' training in cross-disability inclusive education imposed as a condition to appear in the Teachers Eligibility Test (TET), claiming it was inconsistent with the Recruitment Rules.
However, the Court, after hearing submissions from both sides, upheld the existing Recruitment and Promotion Rules. It observed that the educational qualifications for the Special Educator post for Class VI to Class XII clearly prescribe Graduation in any stream with at least 50% marks as an essential qualification, along with a Bachelor of Education degree in Special Education from an RCI-approved institution, six months of specialized training, and passing the TET conducted by the Himachal Pradesh Board of School Education or an authorized agency.
The Court noted that the NCTE notification relied upon by the petitioner did not pertain to the post of Special Educator but rather to other teaching posts, making the petitioner's reliance on it misplaced. The Court emphasized that framing of recruitment qualifications falls within the employer's domain, and the condition of minimum 50% marks in Graduation was neither arbitrary nor unconstitutional.
Further, the Court rejected the petitioner's plea for quashing the six-month cross-disability training requirement, holding it consistent with the statutory framework and job responsibilities.
In conclusion, the Court dismissed the petition, affirming that the Recruitment and Promotion Rules as they stand are valid, do not violate any constitutional or statutory provisions, and do not warrant judicial interference.
This judgment underscores the judiciary's deference to the administrative expertise and discretion of the State in prescribing recruitment qualifications for specialized teaching posts, provided such qualifications are not arbitrary, discriminatory, or ultra vires statutory mandates.
Bottom Line:
Recruitment and Promotion Rules - Prescribing minimum educational qualifications for the post of Special Educator - Requirement of 50% marks in Graduation cannot be termed arbitrary or unconstitutional - Employer's prerogative to decide necessary qualifications for recruitment.
Statutory provision(s):
Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 (Section 23(1)), Recruitment and Promotion Rules notified vide notification dated 10.10.2024, National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) Notification dated 13.11.2019
Som Krishan v. State of H.P., (Himachal Pradesh)(DB) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3023069