LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Kerala HC sets aside preventive detention of BJP Thiruvananthapuram councillor Sugathan

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Kerala HC sets aside preventive detention of BJP Thiruvananthapuram councillor Sugathan

Kochi/Thiruvananthapuram, Oct 6 In a major relief to the ruling BJP, which enjoys a slender majority in the Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation, the Kerala High Court on Tuesday set aside the preventive detention of its councillor R Sugathan and ordered his release from Viyyur Central Jail.


A bench of Justices Anil K Narendran and Muralee Krishna S granted the relief to the BJP councillor on a habeas corpus plea moved by his wife, Aswathi G R.


Sugathan was sent to preventive detention in Viyyur under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act (KAAPA), 2007 for six months from June 8 as he was chargesheeted in several criminal cases.


The court said that the Thiruvananthapuram District Collector has given the detention order on June 8 "in a casual manner without proper application of mind or subjective satisfaction."


The court further said that the councillor was supplied with illegible copies of some of the material documents relied upon by the government for issuing the detention order.


It also said that there was no merit in the contention of Director General of Prosecution, T Asaf Ali, that there is substantial compliance as far as supply of documents to the detenue (Sugathan) was concerned.


"Therefore, the order of preventive detention impugned in the present case is liable to be set aside on the aforesaid ground also," the bench said.


The court noted that even the representations given by the councillor on June 12, after his arrest on June 10, were not considered by the government.


"We have no hesitation in holding that the order of preventive detention issued against the detenue is liable to be set aside on the ground of non-consideration of the representations submitted by the detenue," it added.


It, therefore, set aside the detention order and the June 21 and July 6 orders of the state government approving and confirming it, respectively.


Had Sugathan remained in preventive detention, he would have faced disqualification for missing three consecutive corporation meetings without official permission, potentially putting the BJP's precarious majority in the local body at risk.


The High Court decision is also a setback for the ruling Congress-led UDF, which had issued the detention order and had shown its willingness to move a no-confidence motion in the corporation if the LDF agreed to support it.


Welcoming the judgement, BJP state president Rajeev Chandrasekhar told reporters in Thiruvananthapuram that he was pleased with the outcome as it vindicated the party's stand that the police misused their power.


"The CPI(M) lodged the case, and the V D Satheesan government took it forward. We have no doubt that it was a fake and politically motivated case," he contended.


He also alleged that the CPI(M), during its 10-year rule, used the police to target the opposition and now the Congress-led front is doing the same.


Meanwhile, Congress leader and Thiruvananthapuram corporation councillor K S Sabarinadhan said he was unaware of the merits, based on which the relief was granted to Sugathan and needs to go through the judgment before commenting on it.


"This is a political fight, and we will move forward with it," he told reporters.


He also said that the criminal cases against Sugathan were registered during the time of the CPI(M) rule and had piled up.


Sabarinadhan also said that the government was examining the issue of the interim leave allegedly illegally given to Sugathan during his detention period.


"Our fight against the inefficiency of the corporation will continue," he added.


Later in the day, after Sugathan was released from Viyyur jail, Union Minister of State for Petroleum, Natural Gas and Tourism, Suresh Gopi, received him.


Gopi also interacted with the BJP councillor's family.


Subsequently, Sugathan told the media that it was a politically motivated action against him.


He thanked his party, its workers and other BJP councillors for supporting him and looking after his ward and his family while he was detained.


He claimed he has been targeted for the last several years for taking part in public welfare activities and was branded as a 'goonda' by the CPI(M).


The BJP councillor urged that politics not be used in this manner.


"I am ready to go to jail for the people for as long as needed," he contended.


He also claimed that a lot of youngsters were jailed at Viyyur and housed with hardened criminals.


"People who can be released should be set free," he said.


Sugathan also claimed that the prison premises lacked cleanliness and urged state Home Minister Ramesh Chennithala to visit the jail.


Meanwhile, Chennithala dismissed the reported opposition allegations that Sugathan was released from detention due to collusion between the Congress and BJP.


"This government took all the action, including invoking KAAPA, against him. There was no collusion. There is no need for us to collude with the BJP. Those who colluded are now sitting in the opposition.


"No matter what happens now, the opposition terms everything as collusion with the BJP. They have been harping on it for a long time. They colluded with the BJP for the last 10 years and are blaming us to wash away their wrongs," he told reporters.


Kochi/Thiruvananthapuram, Oct 6 In a major relief to the ruling BJP, which enjoys a slender majority in the Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation, the Kerala High Court on Tuesday set aside the preventive detention of its councillor R Sugathan and ordered his release from Viyyur Central Jail.


A bench of Justices Anil K Narendran and Muralee Krishna S granted the relief to the BJP councillor on a habeas corpus plea moved by his wife, Aswathi G R.


Sugathan was sent to preventive detention in Viyyur under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act (KAAPA), 2007 for six months from June 8 as he was chargesheeted in several criminal cases.


The court said that the Thiruvananthapuram District Collector has given the detention order on June 8 "in a casual manner without proper application of mind or subjective satisfaction."


The court further said that the councillor was supplied with illegible copies of some of the material documents relied upon by the government for issuing the detention order.


It also said that there was no merit in the contention of Director General of Prosecution, T Asaf Ali, that there is substantial compliance as far as supply of documents to the detenue (Sugathan) was concerned.


"Therefore, the order of preventive detention impugned in the present case is liable to be set aside on the aforesaid ground also," the bench said.


The court noted that even the representations given by the councillor on June 12, after his arrest on June 10, were not considered by the government.


"We have no hesitation in holding that the order of preventive detention issued against the detenue is liable to be set aside on the ground of non-consideration of the representations submitted by the detenue," it added.


It, therefore, set aside the detention order and the June 21 and July 6 orders of the state government approving and confirming it, respectively.


Had Sugathan remained in preventive detention, he would have faced disqualification for missing three consecutive corporation meetings without official permission, potentially putting the BJP's precarious majority in the local body at risk.


The High Court decision is also a setback for the ruling Congress-led UDF, which had issued the detention order and had shown its willingness to move a no-confidence motion in the corporation if the LDF agreed to support it.


Welcoming the judgement, BJP state president Rajeev Chandrasekhar told reporters in Thiruvananthapuram that he was pleased with the outcome as it vindicated the party's stand that the police misused their power.


"The CPI(M) lodged the case, and the V D Satheesan government took it forward. We have no doubt that it was a fake and politically motivated case," he contended.


He also alleged that the CPI(M), during its 10-year rule, used the police to target the opposition and now the Congress-led front is doing the same.


Meanwhile, Congress leader and Thiruvananthapuram corporation councillor K S Sabarinadhan said he was unaware of the merits, based on which the relief was granted to Sugathan and needs to go through the judgment before commenting on it.


"This is a political fight, and we will move forward with it," he told reporters.


He also said that the criminal cases against Sugathan were registered during the time of the CPI(M) rule and had piled up.


Sabarinadhan also said that the government was examining the issue of the interim leave allegedly illegally given to Sugathan during his detention period.


"Our fight against the inefficiency of the corporation will continue," he added.


Later in the day, after Sugathan was released from Viyyur jail, Union Minister of State for Petroleum, Natural Gas and Tourism, Suresh Gopi, received him.


Gopi also interacted with the BJP councillor's family.


Subsequently, Sugathan told the media that it was a politically motivated action against him.


He thanked his party, its workers and other BJP councillors for supporting him and looking after his ward and his family while he was detained.


He claimed he has been targeted for the last several years for taking part in public welfare activities and was branded as a 'goonda' by the CPI(M).


The BJP councillor urged that politics not be used in this manner.


"I am ready to go to jail for the people for as long as needed," he contended.


He also claimed that a lot of youngsters were jailed at Viyyur and housed with hardened criminals.


"People who can be released should be set free," he said.


Sugathan also claimed that the prison premises lacked cleanliness and urged state Home Minister Ramesh Chennithala to visit the jail.


Kochi/Thiruvananthapuram, Oct 6 In a major relief to the ruling BJP, which was clinging to a slender majority in the Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation, the Kerala High Court on Tuesday set aside the preventive detention of its councillor R Sugathan and ordered his release from Viyyur Central Jail.


A bench of justices Anil K Narendran and Muralee Krishna S granted the relief to the BJP councillor on a habeas corpus plea moved by his wife, Aswathi G R.


Sugathan was sent to preventive detention in Viyyur under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act (KAAPA), 2007 for six months from June 8 as he was chargesheeted in several criminal cases.


The court said that the detention order of June 8 by the District Collector of Thiruvananthapuram was issued "in a casual manner without proper application of mind or subjective satisfaction."


The court further said that the councillor was supplied with illegible copies of some of the material documents relied upon by the government for issuing the detention order.


It also said that there was no merit in the contention of Director General of Prosecution T Asaf Ali that there is substantial compliance as far as supply of documents to the detenue (Sugathan) was concerned.


"Therefore, the order of preventive detention impugned in the present case is liable to be set aside on the aforesaid ground also," the bench said.


The court noted that even the representations given by the councillor on June 12, after his arrest on June 10, were not considered by the government.


"...we have no hesitation to hold that the order of preventive detention issued against the detenue is liable to be set aside on the ground of non-consideration of the representations submitted by the detenue," it added.


It, therefore, set aside the detention order and the June 21 and July 6 orders of the state government approving and confirming it, respectively.


Had Sugathan remained in preventive detention, he would have faced disqualification for missing three consecutive corporation meetings without official permission, potentially putting the BJP’s precarious majority in the local body at risk.


The High Court decision is also a setback for the ruling Congress-led UDF which had issued the detention order and had shown its willingness to move a no-confidence motion in the corporation if the LDF agreed to support it.


Welcoming the judgement, BJP state president Rajeev Chandrasekhar told reporters in Thiruvananthapuram that he was pleased with the outcome as it vindicated the party's stand that the police misused their power.


"The CPI(M) lodged the case and the V D Satheesan government took it forward. We had no doubt that it was a fake and politically motivated case," he contended.


He also alleged that the CPI(M) during its 10-year rule used the police to target the opposition and now the Congress-led front is doing the same.


Meanwhile, Congress leader and Thiruvananthapuram corporation councillor K S Sabarinadhan said he was unaware of the merits based on which the relief was granted to Sugathan and needs to go through the judgment before commenting on it.


"This is a political fight and we will move forward with it," he told reporters.


He also said that the criminal cases against Sugathan were registered during the time of the CPI(M) rule and had piled up.


Sabarinadhan also said that the government was examining the issue of the interim leave allegedly illegally given to Sugathan during his detention period.


"Our fight against the inefficiency of the corporation will continue," he added.


Kochi, Oct 6 The Kerala High Court on Tuesday set aside the preventive detention of BJP Thiruvananthpuram Corporation councillor R Sugathan and ordered his release from the Viyyur central jail.


A bench of justices Anil K Narendran and Muralee Krishna S gave the relief to the BJP councillor on a plea moved by his wife.


Sugathan was sent to preventive detention in Viyyur under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act (KAAPA), 2007 for six months from June 8.


He was sent to preventive detention as he was involved in several criminal cases.


The court said that the detention order of June 8 by the District Collector of Thiruvananthapuram was issued "in a casual manner without proper application of mind or subjective satisfaction."


It, therefore, set aside the detention order and the June 21 and July 6 orders of the state government approving and confirming it, respectively.

Share this article: