Court says dismissal was unsupported by evidence and contrary to earlier consent order, but grants relief under Article 142 after noting writ petitions were poorly drafted.
The Supreme Court has directed a private school in Maharashtra to pay ?10 lakh each as lump sum compensation to two former employees whose services were terminated in a disciplinary case involving allegations of misappropriation of public money.
A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu held that the termination of senior clerk Prithviraj S. Singh and head clerk Shivadatta R. Singh was unsustainable, especially because the school failed to lead any evidence before the School Tribunal despite a prior consent order of the Bombay High Court specifically permitting it to do so.
The case arose from disciplinary proceedings initiated against the two clerks and the in-charge headmaster of the school. The inquiry committee found the charges proved, but the employees challenged the proceedings before the School Tribunal under Section 9 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977. The Tribunal initially granted interim relief, after which the management approached the Bombay High Court.
In 2005, the High Court passed a consent order allowing the school to apply before the Tribunal for permission to lead evidence to substantiate the misconduct charges. However, the school never filed such an application and led no evidence at all. Despite this, the Tribunal dismissed the employees’ appeals in 2006, relying on documents already on record and observing that the employees had not participated in the inquiry.
When the matter reached the High Court again, the writ petitions filed by the employees did not specifically plead that the school had violated the earlier consent order by failing to lead evidence. The Supreme Court noted that courts are not obliged to entertain arguments not supported by pleadings, and therefore the High Court could not be faulted for not examining those unpleaded issues.
Even so, the apex court expressed concern that there was “no evidence worth the name” before the Tribunal to sustain the charges. The Court also pointed out that the final inquiry reports had not been furnished to the employees before their termination, which it described as a serious flaw in the disciplinary process.
Relying on its extraordinary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court granted equitable relief and ordered the school to pay Rs. 10 lakh each to the two appellants, or to the legal representatives of the deceased appellant, within three months. The amount was directed to be treated as full and final settlement. The Court further held that if payment is delayed beyond three months, the amount would carry interest at 12% per annum until actual payment.
The Court observed that the employees might have been entitled to a larger remedy had their writ petitions been properly drafted and argued, but since that stage had passed, compensation was the most appropriate relief.
Statutory provision(s): Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Article 142 of the Constitution of India, Section 9 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977, Rule 37(2)(a)(iii) of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1981