Court says custody terms in settlement must be obeyed; directs Family Court, Dholpur to arrange child counselling and submits report in sealed cover
The Supreme Court has held a father in clear contempt of its earlier order after he retained custody of his minor son well beyond the limited visitation period granted under a court-recorded settlement with the child’s mother.
A Bench of Justice Sandeep Mehta, Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh was hearing a contempt petition filed by Poornima Gupta in a transfer petition matter arising out of a matrimonial dispute with her husband, Saurav Gupta. The spouses had earlier reached a mutual settlement, which was recorded by the Court on 12 December 2025. Under that settlement, the two children of the marriage were to remain in the custody of the mother, while the father was allowed visitation rights to take them to his parental home in Dholpur, Rajasthan, twice a year for four days each.
According to the mother’s complaint, the father violated those terms by taking the minor son from his school in Delhi on 22 July 2026 under the guise of visitation and thereafter refusing to return him. She alleged that despite repeated requests, a police complaint, and a contempt notice, the child was not handed back.
The father, in his reply, did not dispute that the child had remained with him contrary to the settlement. However, he argued that the child had formed a close bond with him and was unwilling to return to the mother. He also claimed that the child had suffered trauma in the mother’s family and that it would be in the child’s best interest to stay with him at Dholpur.
After interacting with the child and both parents in chambers, the Bench observed that the child appeared to have been “severely tutored” against the mother and sister. The Court also noted, prima facie, signs of substance abuse in the father’s conduct. The judges held that the father was in clear contempt of the Court’s earlier order, since the settlement had placed full custody and guardianship of the children with the mother, subject only to limited visitation rights for the father.
At the same time, the Court said that an abrupt return of the child to the mother could cause further psychological harm, given the child’s current state of mind and the apparent attempt to alienate him from his mother and sister. The Court therefore chose a child-centric remedial approach instead of immediate custody restoration.
The Supreme Court directed the Family Court, Dholpur, to immediately engage a child counsellor to provide counselling to the minor. The counsellor’s primary task will be to restore the child’s faith and trust in his mother and sister and address concerns of sibling alienation. The Court ordered that counselling sessions be held in an influence-free atmosphere, initially twice a week or as decided by the counsellor. If the mother wishes to participate, she may apply before the Family Court, but only with the counsellor’s permission.
The father has been directed to present the child before the Family Court for counselling whenever required and is barred from interfering in the counselling process. The counselling is to take place in a separate room within the Family Court premises, and the father will bear the expenses.
The Court further ordered that the child may continue to reside at Dholpur until the counsellor submits a report. That report is to be placed before the Supreme Court in a sealed cover on 22 January 2027, when the parties and the child must remain present. If the counsellor concludes that the child is ready to be restored to the mother’s guardianship, the report may be forwarded for early listing before the Court.
The matter has now been listed for further hearing on 22 January 2027.
Statutory provision(s): Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, Family Courts Act, 1984, Guardians and Wards Act, 1890
Poornima Gupta v. Saurav Gupta, (SC) : Law Finder Doc id # 3201914