Top court says similarly placed co-convicts cannot be treated differently; upholds stay of conviction granted to Azam Khan and extends same relief to Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr. Tazeen Fatma.
The Supreme Court on Friday ruled that the benefit of stay of conviction granted to senior Samajwadi Party leader Mohammad Azam Khan must also be extended to his son Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan and wife Dr. Tazeen Fatma, holding that the High Court’s refusal to grant them identical relief was arbitrary and violated the constitutional principle of parity.
A Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu dismissed the State of Uttar Pradesh’s challenge to the High Court’s order staying Azam Khan’s conviction, but allowed the separate appeals filed by Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr. Tazeen Fatma. The Court said all three were convicted in the same conspiracy case involving allegedly fraudulent and conflicting birth certificates issued in the name of Abdullah Azam Khan, and there was no legally sustainable basis to treat one differently from the others.
The case arose from an FIR lodged in Rampur in January 2019 under provisions of the Indian Penal Code relating to criminal conspiracy, cheating, forgery and use of forged documents. The High Court had suspended the sentences of all three convicts, but had stayed the conviction only in the case of Mohammad Azam Khan. The son and wife were denied the same relief, prompting the present appeals.
The Supreme Court held that while a stay of conviction is an exceptional remedy and not to be granted routinely, once a court decides to extend such relief to one co-convict, it must record clear and intelligible reasons if it chooses to deny the same to others standing on the same footing. In the absence of such reasons, the differentiation is arbitrary and offends Article 14 of the Constitution.
The Bench also observed that conviction has serious consequences beyond imprisonment, including stigma, loss of reputation and damage to personal dignity, all of which fall within the protection of Article 21. The Court relied on earlier precedent, including Afjal Ansari v. State of U.P. and Ravikant S. Patil v. Sarvabhouma S. Bagali, to reiterate that stay of conviction may be justified where irreversible harm would otherwise follow.
At the same time, the Court clarified that stay of conviction cannot be sought as a matter of political convenience or electoral strategy. It emphasised that courts must balance the sanctity of conviction with the grave prejudice that may be caused if the conviction is allowed to operate during the pendency of a bona fide revision.
Concluding that the High Court had failed to explain any meaningful distinction between Azam Khan and the other two convicts, the Supreme Court set aside the denial of relief to Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr. Tazeen Fatma. Their convictions, like that of Azam Khan, will remain stayed until their criminal revision petitions are decided by the High Court.
The Court directed the High Court to hear and decide the revisions expeditiously and independently on merits, without being influenced by the Supreme Court’s observations.
Statutory provision(s): Section 389(1), Section 397, Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, Section 120B, Section 420, Section 467, Section 468, Section 471 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, Article 14, Article 21 of the Constitution of India
State of U.P. v. Mohammad Azam Khan, (SC) : Law Finder Doc id # 3123059