LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Tamil Nadu urges SC to stay HC order permitting lighting of traditional Karthigai Deepam

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Tamil Nadu urges SC to stay HC order permitting lighting of traditional Karthigai Deepam

New Delhi, Nov 17 The Tamil Nadu government on Tuesday urged the Supreme Court to stay the Madras High Court's direction permitting the lighting of the traditional Karthigai Deepam lamp atop a stone pillar, known as the Deepathoon, near the Dargah on Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai district.


A bench comprising Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi heard arguments for over one-and-a-half hours from the state government and other authorities opposing the high court's direction.


The hearing will continue on Wednesday at 2 pm.


Seeking urgent interim relief, the state government pointed out that the Karthigai Deepam festival, falling on November 24 this year, was approaching and that the lamp would have to be lit at the "disputed" location if the high court's direction was not stayed.


Senior advocate Jaideep Gupta, appearing for the state government, said that there was no established custom of lighting the ceremonial lamp at the Deepathoon.


Taking the bench through earlier judgments of the Madras High Court, he said that previous proceedings had rejected the demand for lighting the lamp at the disputed location.


Gupta said the temple priests and traditional functionaries, known as Sthanikars, had affirmed that in accordance with the Agamas, the lamp was traditionally lit near the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple and not at the Deepathoon near the Dargah.


He said that in the absence of an established customary right, no writ of mandamus could be issued directing the temple authorities to adopt a different practice.


"If the temple says this is the practice, normally the courts will not interfere," he said, adding that the petitioners had failed to discharge the burden of proving the existence of a custom permitting the lighting of the lamp at the Deepathoon.


"One of the things stated in the judgment is, generally in Tamil Nadu, temple lamp is lit on the hilltop. That is not proof of custom.


"The proof of custom is what the sthanikars have said regarding the lighting of deepam (sacred lamp) at Uchi Pillaiyar Temple," he argued.


Senior advocate Shekhar Naphade, appearing for the commissioner of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Department, also opposed the high court's direction and urged the court to preserve the existing arrangement.


"If some practice has been going on for 100 years, why change it?" Naphade said.


Earlier, the Tamil Nadu HR&CE Department had strongly opposed the petition seeking Archaeological Survey of India's (ASI) control over the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy temple and Thirupparankundram hill, and also changes in the traditional Karthigai Deepam celebrations.


The Karthigai Deepam controversy at the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy temple at Madurai centres on a dispute over where and by whom the deepam should be lit on the Thirupparankundram hill.


For decades, the deepam was lit at the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar temple on the lower slopes. Hindu groups had sought permission to light the lamp at the Deepathoon, an ancient stone lamp pillar located higher up the hill, approximately 50 metres away from the Hazrat Sultan Sikandar Badusha Auliya dargah.


In an affidavit filed before the bench, the HR&CE Department opposed the plea which sought a direction to the ASI to take over the temple and the Thirupparankundram hill, saying the temple's ownership and the existing religious practices have been settled through decades of judicial proceedings.


HR&CE Commissioner T G Vinay said the hill is owned by the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy temple, Thirupparankundram, to the extent recognised by a civil court decree of 1923, which was subsequently restored by the Privy Council in 1931.


The affidavit opposed three reliefs sought by petitioner Hindu Dharma Parishad seeking the handing over of the entire temple and hill to the ASI, keeping a lamp burning round the clock at a stone pillar described as the Deepathoon and illuminating the entire hill with lamps during Karthigai Deepam.


"A title so settled cannot be disturbed and the administration of a religious endowment entrusted by statute to the HR&CE cannot be wrested away and handed over to the ASI upon a petition that pleads no ground in law and seeks the relief in the teeth of a concluded civil adjudication of title," the affidavit said.


On the contentious issue of lighting the Karthigai Deepam, the HR&CE commissioner maintained that the festival lamp has traditionally been lit at the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar temple and not at the hilltop or the stone pillar now being described as the Deepathoon.


It further referred to historical records of attempts made in 1862 and 1912 to light lamps near the summit of the hillock where the dargah is situated.


Opposing the demand for an ASI takeover, the commissioner contended that archaeological protection at Thirupparankundram extends only to specified features, including the rock-cut cave and inscriptions, and not to the entire hill or the functioning temple.


It cautioned that permitting lighting at multiple locations on the hill, particularly in the vicinity of the dargah, could disturb the existing arrangements and create law and order complications at a site with a history of communal tension.

Share this article: