Court holds arbitral tribunal's omission to consider material contractual obligation of good faith under Share Purchase and Shareholders Agreement violates natural justice and public policy, partially setting aside award under Section 34 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
In a significant judgment delivered on November 3, 2026, the Delhi High Court, presided over by Justice Om Prakash Shukla, partially set aside an arbitral award rendered in an international commercial arbitration between MMTC Ltd. and PAMP Holding Mauritius Ltd. The dispute arose from transactions under a Share Purchase and Shareholders Agreement (SPSHA) involving their joint venture, MMTC-PAMP India Private Limited (MPIPL), established to operate a gold and silver refinery in India.
MMTC, a Government of India undertaking, challenged payments totalling approximately Rs. 71.25 crore made by MPIPL to PAMP and its associated company MKS Switzerland SA under separate Dore Sourcing and Process Know-How Licence Agreements. MMTC alleged that these payments breached the SPSHA, particularly the obligation of "Good Faith" under Article 34 of the agreement. It contended that PAMP, as majority shareholder, misused its control to orchestrate these agreements without MMTC's consultation, thus diverting funds unfairly.
The Arbitral Tribunal had earlier dismissed MMTC's claims, concluding that the agreements were entered into on an arm's-length basis and that the SPSHA did not require PAMP to provide services free of charge. The Tribunal also held it lacked jurisdiction to modify or cancel these agreements as the counterparties were not parties to the arbitration and rejected MMTC's restitution claims.
On appeal, the Delhi High Court emphasized the limited scope of judicial interference in international commercial arbitral awards under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, especially after the 2015 amendments that narrowed grounds like patent illegality. However, the Court underscored that a failure by the arbitral tribunal to adjudicate a material issue submitted to it-such as the contractual obligation of good faith-amounts to a failure to exercise jurisdiction under Section 34(2)(a)(iv), which can result in setting aside the award if it causes material prejudice.
The Court examined the SPSHA provisions, particularly Article 34, which mandates all transactions between the parties and their controlled companies be conducted in good faith and, where no terms are agreed, on arm's-length basis. While the Tribunal considered whether the transactions were arm's length, it did not independently adjudicate whether the execution and approval of the Dore Sourcing and Licence Agreements complied with the good faith obligation.
Rejecting the Tribunal's approach, the Court held that the non-adjudication of the "Good Faith" issue was a serious omission that violated fundamental principles of natural justice and the most basic notions of justice under the public policy of India. The Court relied on precedents, including the Division Bench decision in Ssangyong Engineering & Construction Co. Ltd. v. NHAI, which distinguishes between an erroneous adjudication and a failure to adjudicate a submitted issue, the latter being a valid ground for interference.
The Court therefore set aside the portion of the arbitral award dismissing MMTC's claims relating to breach of good faith under the SPSHA and the associated monetary relief, allowing the parties to pursue these claims afresh either in arbitration or through other legal remedies. The Court upheld the Tribunal's dismissal of claims that MMTC had expressly withdrawn and maintained that the arbitration award's costs orders would also be set aside correspondingly.
This judgment reinforces the criticality of tribunals addressing all material issues raised by parties, especially obligations as fundamental as good faith in joint venture agreements. It clarifies that even in the constrained scope of interference applicable to international commercial arbitrations, failure to decide such issues can constitute grounds for setting aside awards on jurisdictional and public policy bases.
Bottom Line:
Arbitration award in international commercial arbitration can be set aside if the arbitral tribunal fails to adjudicate a material issue, such as compliance with a contractual obligation of "Good Faith," which results in material prejudice to a party.
Statutory provision(s):
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 34(2)(a)(iv), Section 34(2)(b)(ii), Explanation 1(iii) to Section 34(2)(b)(ii), Section 34(2)(a)(iii), Section 34(2A)
MMTC Ltd. v. PAMP Holding Mauritius Ltd., (Delhi) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019176