LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Kerala High Court Rules Arbitration Clause Requiring Mutual Consent Not Binding Under Arbitration Act

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Kerala High Court Rules Arbitration Clause Requiring Mutual Consent Not Binding Under Arbitration Act

Court holds that absence of mutual consent precludes appointment of arbitrator under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996


In a significant judgment delivered on November 3, 2026, the Kerala High Court, led by Chief Justice Soumen Sen, dismissed an application for the appointment of an arbitrator in a dispute arising from a Joint Venture Agreement (JVA) dated August 20, 2016, between V.K Varghese (petitioner) and Anta Builders and Developers Pvt Ltd (respondents). The Court's ruling clarifies the legal position regarding arbitration clauses that require mutual consent of parties before referring disputes to arbitration.


The petitioner alleged that the respondents failed to fulfill their contractual obligations under the JVA, resulting in loss and damage. Invoking Clause 12 of the agreement, which contains the dispute resolution mechanism, the petitioner issued a notice under Section 21 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (the Act), nominating a senior advocate as arbitrator and calling upon the respondents to appoint their arbitrator within 30 days. The respondents neither replied nor nominated an arbitrator, thereby preventing the constitution of an arbitral tribunal as per the agreed procedure.


Consequently, the petitioner sought the High Court's intervention under Section 11(6) of the Act for appointment of an arbitrator. However, the respondents contended that Clause 12.2 of the JVA was not a binding arbitration agreement under Section 7 of the Act because it mandated mutual consent at the time of dispute for arbitration to proceed. The respondents relied heavily on the Supreme Court's decision in Jagdish Chander v. Ramesh Chander (2007) which held that a clause stating "the dispute shall be referred for arbitration if the parties so determine" does not constitute a binding arbitration agreement but merely an enabling provision contingent on mutual consent.


The Court carefully analyzed the arbitration clause, which stipulated: "All disputes and differences ... shall, upon mutual consent of parties, be referred to arbitration..." and further described the appointment procedure for arbitrators once mutual consent is given. The Court observed that the clause contains two parts - a prerequisite of mutual consent for arbitration and the procedure for appointing arbitrators upon such consent. The Court emphasized that these parts are interlinked; without mutual consent, the appointment procedure cannot be triggered.


Rejecting the petitioner's reliance on decisions such as Tarun Dhameja v. Sunil Dhameja (2024) and Shubham Equipment Private Limited v. Rothwell Water Company Limited (2026), where arbitration clauses clearly indicated an intention to arbitrate upon failure of amicable settlement, the Court distinguished those cases on the basis that in the present matter, the clause did not impose a definitive obligation to arbitrate but rather provided for arbitration only if both parties mutually agreed after the dispute arose.


The Court reaffirmed the principle that an arbitration agreement must contain an unequivocal, binding obligation to submit disputes to arbitration. It is not sufficient that arbitration is merely a possible or optional mode of dispute resolution contingent on future agreement. The Court relied on authoritative pronouncements from the Supreme Court in Nagreeka Indcon Products Pvt. Ltd v. Cargocare Logistics (India) Pvt. Ltd (2026), Cox & Kings Ltd. v. SAP India Pvt. Ltd (2024), and K.K. Modi v. K.N. Modi (1998), which collectively underscore that the source of the arbitral tribunal's jurisdiction is the parties' consent, manifested in a binding arbitration agreement.


Concluding that the clause in question did not constitute an arbitration agreement enforceable under Section 7 of the Act, the Court held that jurisdiction under Section 11 for appointment of an arbitrator could not be invoked. The application was dismissed with no order as to costs.


This judgment is a crucial reminder that parties drafting arbitration clauses must ensure clear, unequivocal language demonstrating a binding intention to arbitrate disputes without requiring a further agreement at the time of dispute. Clauses that make arbitration conditional on mutual consent at the dispute stage are not treated as binding arbitration agreements and will not attract the Court's power to appoint arbitrators under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.


Bottom Line:

Arbitration Clause - A clause stipulating that disputes shall be referred to arbitration only upon mutual consent of the parties does not constitute a binding arbitration agreement under Section 7 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The absence of mutual consensus precludes invoking jurisdiction under Section 11 for appointment of an arbitrator.


Statutory provision(s):

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 7, Section 9, Section 11(6), Section 21


V.K Varghese v. Anta Builders and Developers Pvt Ltd, (Kerala) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019172

Share this article: