Court directs immediate return of academic certificates to student, emphasizing that withholding certificates as fee security is unlawful and violates student rights
In a significant judgment delivered on November 5, 2026, the Telangana High Court, presided over by Justice Juvvadi Sridevi, held that educational institutions cannot withhold the original academic certificates of students as a means to recover outstanding dues. The court ruled in favor of Kolakatla Shravan Kumar, a petitioner who completed his MBBS course but faced financial constraints in paying the balance tuition fees. The college had retained his original certificates, thereby preventing him from participating in the NEET PG 2026 counselling process and obstructing his ability to obtain permanent medical registration.
The petitioner, Kolakatla Shravan Kumar, had submitted all his original academic certificates at the time of admission, including SSC and Intermediate mark memos, NEET Rank Card, Hall Ticket, Transfer and Migration Certificates, and Bonafide Certificates. After successfully completing the course and the compulsory internship, he received a provisional certificate and an internship completion certificate from the university and had registered with the Telangana Medical Council. However, due to non-payment of the remaining tuition fee of Rs.11,75,000 for the final year, the college withheld his original certificates.
The petitioner argued that this withholding was illegal and unconstitutional, causing irreparable harm to his career prospects, particularly since the NEET PG counselling required original certificates for verification. His counsel submitted that such retention was a violation of his rights and no legal provision authorized the college to keep his certificates as security for fee recovery.
The court agreed, stating that the original certificates are the exclusive property of the student, and no statute or legal authority permits an educational institution to retain them to recover dues. It emphasized that even if the college had a legitimate monetary claim, it must pursue legal proceedings for recovery rather than unlawfully withholding certificates. The court further noted that such withholding hinders a student's career and livelihood and cannot be justified on the grounds of outstanding fees.
Accordingly, the Telangana High Court directed the college to return all original certificates to the petitioner within one week from the date of the order. The court's decision reinforces the rights of students and sets a clear precedent against the unlawful retention of academic credentials by educational institutions.
Bottom Line:
Educational institutions cannot withhold original academic certificates of students to recover dues. Such retention is unlawful and violative of the rights of students.
Statutory provision(s): Constitution of India, Articles 14 and 19.
Kolakatla Shravan Kumar v. State of Telangana, (Telangana) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019149