Court Rules State Bar Council Cannot Levy Additional Fees Beyond Bar Council of India's Revised Schedule; Petition Challenging Fee Increase Dismissed
In a significant judgment delivered on October 27, 2026, the Telangana High Court, through Justice N. Tukaramji, clarified the legal position on fees payable by advocates seeking to resume practice after voluntary suspension. The writ petition filed by advocate K. Sree Hareesh Kumar challenged the Bar Council of Telangana's demand of Rs.10,000 as resumption fee, contending that it was arbitrary, illegal, and violative of constitutional rights.
The petitioner, who had voluntarily suspended his practice in 2001 upon joining employment and sought to resume after retirement in 2025, was initially informed that a fee of Rs.12,000 was payable. Upon inquiry, he was told that the resumption fee had been enhanced from Rs.5,000 to Rs.10,000 following the Bar Council of Telangana's General Body resolution dated April 6, 2024. The petitioner argued that the increase lacked statutory authority and violated Articles 14, 19(1)(g), and 21 of the Indian Constitution, relying heavily on the Supreme Court's ruling in Gaurav Kumar v. Union of India (2024) which dealt with enrolment fees.
On the other hand, the Bar Council of Telangana and the Bar Council of India defended the fee increase by pointing to the revised fee schedule effective August 6, 2024, under Part VIII of the Bar Council of India Rules. The Bar Council of India's resolution prescribed Rs.10,000 as the fee payable to the State Bar Council for resumption of practice, along with Rs.4,000 payable to the Bar Council of India itself. They argued that the fee was regulatory and compensatory, intended to cover administrative costs such as application scrutiny, biometric verification, antecedent checks, and maintenance of the State roll.
The Court closely examined the statutory provisions under the Advocates Act, 1961, particularly Sections 6, 28, and 49, which confer exclusive authority on the Bar Council of India to prescribe fees related to enrolment and resumption of advocates. It was held that while the State Bar Council can collect fees prescribed by the Bar Council of India, it cannot impose any additional fees beyond that limit. The Court also distinguished the Gaurav Kumar judgment as primarily concerning fresh enrolment fees and noted that it does not preclude fees prescribed for resumption of practice, provided they are authorized by statute or rules.
The Court further observed that the petitioner's application for resumption fell after the effective date of the revised fee schedule, making the Rs.10,000 fee the lawful charge. It rejected the petitioner's claim that the fee was excessive or unconstitutional, affirming that a reasonable regulatory fee does not infringe on the fundamental right to practice a profession. However, the Court clarified that any other contributions, such as to the Advocates Welfare Fund, are distinct and must be levied strictly under the statutory framework.
In conclusion, the Telangana High Court dismissed the challenge against the Rs.10,000 resumption fee to the extent it aligns with the Bar Council of India's revised rules, but restrained the State Bar Council from imposing any unauthorized additional fees. The petitioner was already permitted to resume practice upon payment of the lawful fee, and the Court's order provides clarity on the limits of fee imposition by State Bar Councils vis-a-vis the Bar Council of India's authority.
This judgment reinforces the principle that regulatory fees for advocates must have a clear statutory or rule-based foundation, protecting legal professionals from arbitrary or excessive charges by State Bar Councils.
Bottom Line:
Advocates Act, 1961 - A State Bar Council cannot levy a resumption fee exceeding the amount prescribed by the Bar Council of India under the applicable BCI Rules.
Statutory provision(s):
Sections 6, 28(1), 28(2)(d), 49(1)(h) of the Advocates Act, 1961; Part VIII of Bar Council of India Rules; Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 21 of the Constitution of India.
K.Sree Hareesh Kumar v. Bar Council of Telangana, (Telangana) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3019155