LawFinder.news
LawFinder.news

Calcutta High Court Sets Aside Demolition Order Against Sujoy Sarkar, Cites Lack of Evidence for Unauthorized Construction

LAW FINDER NEWS NETWORK | |
Calcutta High Court Sets Aside Demolition Order Against Sujoy Sarkar, Cites Lack of Evidence for Unauthorized Construction

Court directs Howrah Municipal Corporation to provide petitioner an opportunity to submit documents and pass a reasoned order after hearing all parties


In a significant judgment dated 10th November 2026, the Calcutta High Court has quashed a demolition order issued by the Assistant Engineer of the Howrah Municipal Corporation against Sujoy @ Sujay Sarkar. The order, dated 28th September 2026, pertained to the alleged unauthorized construction by the petitioner. The Court found that the demolition order was primarily based on an alleged admission by the petitioner regarding the unauthorized nature of the construction, an admission which the Court held was not substantiated by the record.


The petitioner, represented by Mr. Shibaji Kumar Das and Mr. Dipendu Sarkar, contended that at no point did he admit to the unauthorized nature of his construction before the municipal authority. The document relied upon by the Corporation, dated 3rd April 2025 and annexed in the writ petition, was scrutinized by the Court. It was observed that this document did not constitute an admission; rather, it was a request by the petitioner for additional time to submit relevant documents concerning the construction.


The Howrah Municipal Corporation, represented by Ms. Sonal Sinha and Mr. Sandipan Das, maintained that no relevant documents were produced during the proceedings to demonstrate the legality of the construction. Additionally, respondent no.7, supported by Senior Counsel Mr. Buddhadeb Ghoshal, asserted that the demolition steps were initiated following a complaint lodged by them, and highlighted that a civil suit filed by the petitioner was still pending.


After careful consideration, Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya found that the demolition order was not justified due to the absence of conclusive evidence that the petitioner admitted unauthorized construction. The Court emphasized the principles of natural justice by directing the Assistant Engineer, Borough-II, Howrah Municipal Corporation, to grant the petitioner and respondent no.7 an opportunity to present all relevant documents and arguments. The authority was instructed to hear both parties and thereafter pass a reasoned order within eight weeks from the date of the judgment.


This ruling underscores the importance of fair procedure and the need for municipal authorities to base demolition orders on clear and substantiated evidence rather than presumptions or alleged admissions. It also provides the petitioner a fair chance to defend his position in the ongoing dispute concerning the construction.


The writ petition filed by Sujoy Sarkar has been disposed of accordingly, with no order as to costs.


Bottom Line:

Demolition order based on alleged admission of unauthorized construction by petitioner set aside due to lack of evidence proving such admission. Opportunity granted to petitioner to present relevant documents before the authority.


Statutory provision(s):

Demolition of unauthorized construction.


Sujoy @ Sujay Sarkar v. Howrah Municipal Corporation, (Calcutta) : Law Finder Doc Id # 3023062

Share this article: